5 things worse for your car insurance than an accident

5 things worse for your car insurance than an accident


It seems that there are other driving infractions and changes to your coverage which will crank up your auto rates even quite an accident. While a DUI is a clear one, who would have thought that a lousy credit rating, adding a teenage driver or maybe speeding tickets may result during a bigger bump than an accident?

What raises your auto insurance rates quite an accident?

We checked out 43 driving situations encompassing common tickets, accidents, and scenarios to ascertain which of them end in a better rate increase than an accident. An accident claim means you'll typically pay around 32%, or $459, more a year for insurance. Here are scenarios that will cost you far more than an accident.

How much adding a teenager driver raises your insurance

Adding a teenager to your policy will hike your rates quite an accident.

According to our data, putting a 16-year old male on your policy will end in a 160% increase, which translates into $2,292 on average. If your new driver is female, the pain may be a bit less, but not much, expect a 125% increase or $1,782.

The reason why automobile insurance for teens is dear is that teens are high-risk drivers, and statistically, males are worse than females. consistent with data from the Insurance Information Institute which culled data from federal researchers:


  • Motor vehicle crashes are the leading explanation for death among teens
  • Drivers age 15 to twenty accounted for 9% of all drivers involved in fatal crashes in 2016 and 12 percent of all drivers involved in police-reported crashes.
  • 1,908 drivers ages 15 to twenty died in automobile crashes in 2016

Inexperience on the road can cause accidents, which ends up in claims. "It's statistically proven that since teenager drivers do not have the experience that their parents have behind the wheel, they take longer to react to certain situations they're faced with when driving," says Charlotte Burr with AZ Insurance Team.

Expect to pay higher rates until age 25, though your premium should drop a touch for each year your teen stays ticket and accident-free, says Penny Gusner, consumer analyst for Insurance.com.

DUI and automobile insurance 

A driving while intoxicated conviction will hike your rates, on the average, by 79%, or $1,131 yearly. In many nations, a DUI stays on your record for five, seven, 10, or maybe more, years, so this infraction adds up over time, compared to accidents, which usually drop off your record after three years.

Still, DUI insurance rates vary significantly among automobile insurance companies. An Insurance.com analysis found you'll save to $2,000 annually by comparison shopping.

Reckless driving

Getting cited for reckless driving may be a huge red flag for insurers. they're going to raise your rates a mean of 73% or $1,046.

"A reckless driving ticket is typically enough to cause an outsized increase in premium because most insurance companies would classify that as a 'major' violation,” advises David Miller, VP Client Executive with The Plexus Groupe.

The definition of reckless driving can vary by state but generally. However, if you're out on the road showing a willful or wanton disregard for safety, you'll have a reckless driving ticket in your future. Just a couple of actions which will put one among these tickets on your record:


  • Driving 25 miles per hour (or more) over the regulation 
  • Street racing another vehicle
  • Attempting to elude a policeman 
  • Passing another vehicle on a two-lane highway when visibility of oncoming traffic is restricted 


In addition, this sort of infraction may stay your driving record (and your insurance record) for much longer than an easy ticket or maybe an accident. Reckless driving is taken into account a "serious" offense by enforcement and insurers so expect it to ding your rates for five to seven years counting on where you reside.

Does bad credit affect car insurance? Yes!

Insurers put tons of stock in credit ratings. You'll pay a better premium if yours is sub-par.

"Insurance companies have shown a correlation between those with bad credit and a better rate of filing claims. Insurance data shows that those that have bad credit tend to form more claims and people claims tend to be more costly," says Gusner.

Insurers started using credit data within the 1990s and now most insurance companies take under consideration your credit scores when setting premiums. Currently, there are only three states that prohibit insurers from using credit scores when setting rates, California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts.

Car insurance for drivers with bad credit costs a mean of 71% or about $990 more a year than for those with good credit. But, if you shop your policy after a credit ding, you'll still save. Insurance.com data show that drivers with bad credit can trim up to $2,000 from their yearly policy cost, on the average, by comparison, shopping with multiple insurers.

Two speeding tickets: Double trouble for automobile insurance rates

While one ticket on your record is typically not the top of the planet, if you get two during a short period of your time (think a year or less), your insurer may label you a high-risk driver and your rates will absolutely be headed up.

According to our data, two speeding tickets of 11 mph or more over the limit on your record will end in a 43% increase or $610. one ticket on your record may be a bit more manageable with the speed increase falling within the 22% to 30% range. you'll be paying these higher rates for a minimum of three years as you await the tickets to drop off your record.

It should be noted that the precise increase will vary by both the state and insurance firm.

How much does automobile insurance go up after an accident?

While we've highlighted several instances worse for your rates than an accident, bear in mind that your insurance rates are typically getting to spike if you're involved during a crash. As outlined within the table below, about 26% to 32% on the average.

Bodily injury insurance covers the prices related to injuries to the opposite people involved in the accident. This includes medical bills, loss of income, legal fees if you're sued also as pain and suffering. A bodily injury claim will raise your rates 32% or $459 on the average.

The rate increase will vary by the severity of the resulting claim (how much the insurance firm has got to pay out) also as what percentage other infractions you've got on your driving record.

Accidents and claims tend to remain on your insurance record and impact your rates for a minimum of three years and sometimes five. That varies by insurer. If you've got an accident claim on your record and add another, expect your premium to travel up dramatically.

For example, Insurance.com rate analysis shows that two at-fault property damage accidents over $2,000 trigger a 110% increase, or $1,572, annually. this suggests that you simply have two at-fault accidents (and claims) on your record and therefore the insurance firm spent over $2,000 on all. Property damage insurance covers others' property that you simply damage together with your car and while it's mostly repairing the opposite person's vehicle, it also can be wont to repair fences, mailboxes or maybe landscaping that you simply managed to run over.

How do I lower my automobile insurance rates?

Accidents, tickers and other scenarios we've outlined will cause higher premiums but that does not mean you're stuck paying sky-high insurance rates forever. There are a couple of belongings you can do to lower your premium:

Shop your coverage: Shopping around for various coverage is usually the simplest thanks to lowering your premium. Insurers rate risk differently (they all have proprietary systems) so premiums can vary dramatically between insurance companies. Always confirm you're comparing apples to apples when it involves deductibles and coverage levels.

"If your rates have gone up dramatically, you ought to get quotes from a minimum of three other insurance companies to ascertain if you'll find a cheaper rate with a special insurer," advises Gusner.

One thing you ought to never do is drop your coverage levels to save lots of money. While this might end in savings, it is often an enormous financial mistake if you're involved during a serious accident.

Fight the ticket: While this would possibly not work for many of those infractions, if you discover yourself on the hook for a reckless driving ticket (or your second speeding ticket), you ought to do what you'll to fight it. Reckless driving is taken into account a serious infraction so if there's any possibility of getting it reduced you ought to take it. Hiring an attorney is perhaps the simplest option for a serious ticket like reckless driving.

The same advice stands for speeding tickets. "We recommend consulting with an attorney even for speeding tickets. In many nations, a traffic ticket attorney can get a moving violation ticket reduced to a non-moving violation, which can help keep points off your driving record. this is often the key to maintaining lower rates," advises John Espenschied of Insurance Brokers Group.

Raise your deductible: Increasing your deductible will help lower your premium. "Increasing your collision deductible should make a reasonably good dent in your premium. you'll reach rather quickly. for instance, you're going from a $500 deductible to a $1,000 deductible and you save $125 per annum. Four accident-free years and you reach and each year thereafter, you're money ahead," says Jim Kirchen, president of Kirchen Insurance, based in Wisconsin. Always choose a deductible that you simply can easily afford within the event you've got to form a claim.

Discounts: Insurance companies offer many automobile insurance discounts and that they will all help lower your rates. Always confirm you're getting the discounts you're entitled to receive. Ask your agent to try to to a reduction review to form sure all available discounts are being applied to your policy. as an example, if you add a car once you add a teenage driver, you'll get a multi-car discount. Buying car and residential insurance from an equivalent company, called bundling, also nets a mean discount of 11% on your automobile insurance, consistent with Insurance.com data.

Adding a teenage driver: Ways to save lots of 

An inexperienced teen driver on your policy will raise your rates regardless of what but there are a couple of belongings you can do to assist lower your costs:

Good student discount: If your teen driver may be a good student (B average or better), you ought to be ready to wrangle an honest student discount from your insurer. The discount will vary by insurer but expect around 10%.

Defensive driving course: Many insurers offer a reduction for drivers who pass a defensive driving course. ask your insurer for approved courses and send your teen.

Safe, slow and older car: Older cars tend to be cheaper to insure, and making your teen driver drive a sedan rather than a sports car will absolutely economize. additionally, if the car is sufficiently old, you'll be ready to dump certain coverages.

Accident forgiveness: "Add accident and violation forgiveness to your auto policy. Not all auto insurers offer this but if you've got access thereto, you ought to definitely add it to your policy. If your teenager causes an accident, your rates will probably double or triple without this endorsement," warns Burr.